Roven / Head to head / A Staffing Agency vs A Contingency Recruiter

A STAFFING AGENCY VS A CONTINGENCY RECRUITER

A Staffing Agency vs A Contingency Recruiter: which one should a small employer use?

A Staffing Agency is a staffing agency; its model is hourly markup on the agency's payroll; conversion fee to hire direct. A Contingency Recruiter is a recruiter; its model is percentage of first-year salary, paid on placement. They are not interchangeable, and the right pick depends on how often you hire and who you are trying to reach. Here is the honest version, from a company that competes with both.

Skip to the verdict

Side by side

A Staffing Agency vs A Contingency Recruiter at a glance.

A STAFFING AGENCYA CONTINGENCY RECRUITER
PRICING MODELHourly markup on the agency's payroll; conversion fee to hire directPercentage of first-year salary, paid on placement
BUILT FORTemporary, seasonal and temp-to-hire roles where someone else handling payroll is part of the value.Specialized, senior or hard-to-fill roles where a human network is the only way in.
STRONGEST ATGenuinely temporary needs. A two-week cover for a medical leave is what agencies are for.Niche and senior roles where the right people are not applying anywhere and have to be found and persuaded.
WEAKEST ATA one-time fee ends. An hourly uplift runs for the life of the placement, which is why a long assignment can cost several times a direct-hire fee.Finding a $90,000 hire is not three times the work of finding a $30,000 hire, but the percentage says it is.
STAY IFThe role is truly temporary and you do not want the person on your payroll at all.The role is senior, specialized or confidential, and the percentage is small next to the cost of leaving it empty.

We describe A Staffing Agency and A Contingency Recruiter in general terms and quote no prices, because their pricing changes and a wrong number on a page about honesty would be worth less than nothing. Check their current rates yourself, then compare. If anything here is out of date, tell us at hello@rovenhr.com and we will correct it. Last reviewed 2026-10-13.

A Staffing Agency

How A Staffing Agency works, and who it is for.

Staffing agencies place a worker on their own payroll and bill you an hourly rate well above the wage. That markup applies to every hour worked for as long as the placement lasts, and converting the person to your own payroll usually carries a separate buyout fee.

Strengths

Watch out for

A Contingency Recruiter

How A Contingency Recruiter works, and who it is for.

Contingency recruiters typically charge a percentage of the hire's first-year salary, commonly quoted between 15% and 25%. The better the person you hire, the more the introduction costs you.

Strengths

Watch out for

Verdict

Pick based on how you hire, not on which one you have heard of.

PICK A STAFFING AGENCY IF

The role is truly temporary and you do not want the person on your payroll at all.

PICK A CONTINGENCY RECRUITER IF

The role is senior, specialized or confidential, and the percentage is small next to the cost of leaving it empty.

A THIRD OPTION

If you post a few roles a year, hire locally, and are tired of paying before anyone is hired, Roven is free to post, verifies every employer, shows pay on every listing, and charges one flat fee only when a candidate accepts your offer. Your response rate is public, which is why candidates take the listing seriously.

Founding employers - first 100, nationwide

Try it while it costs nothing.

Placement fees are waived entirely right now. The first 100 verified employers in the US lock founding terms: free for 12 months after pricing activates, then 50% off list pricing for life.

Create your employer account Talk to us first

Questions

Straight answers.

Is A Staffing Agency or A Contingency Recruiter better for a small business?

A Staffing Agency fits best when the role is truly temporary and you do not want the person on your payroll at all. A Contingency Recruiter fits best when the role is senior, specialized or confidential, and the percentage is small next to the cost of leaving it empty. If neither describes you, and you mainly want a verified listing that gets answered applications without paying before a hire, that is what Roven is for.

Which is cheaper, A Staffing Agency or A Contingency Recruiter?

It depends entirely on how often you hire. A Staffing Agency charges hourly markup on the agency's payroll; conversion fee to hire direct; A Contingency Recruiter charges percentage of first-year salary, paid on placement. We do not quote either one's prices because they change. Check both, then price a year of your actual hiring on each.

Can I post on A Staffing Agency and A Contingency Recruiter at the same time?

Yes, and many employers do. The cost is managing two applicant streams and answering both, which is where response rates quietly collapse.

What is Roven and how is it different from both?

Roven is a verified hiring marketplace. Posting is free, every employer is identity-checked, every listing shows pay, and the only charge is a flat placement fee when a candidate accepts your offer. Employers' response rates are public. List pricing is $249 per contract, part-time or temporary hire and $499 per full-time W-2 hire, with launch pricing currently at $99 and $199. Placement fees are waived entirely while the marketplace grows, and the first 100 verified employers keep 50% off list pricing for life.